Skip to main content

BFSG Warning Letter (Abmahnung): What to Do Next

Information about the article

Portrait of Dmitry Dugarev

Author: Dmitry Dugarev

Consultant for digital accessibility & IT compliance

Last updated on:

You have received a BFSG warning letter: a German Abmahnung because your website is not accessible. It works much like a cease-and-desist letter. A lawyer claims that your website has accessibility barriers. The lawyer demands money and a signed cease-and-desist declaration, often with a short deadline.

The BFSG (Barrierefreiheitsstärkungsgesetz) is Germany's implementation of the European Accessibility Act (EAA). This article is for website owners who want to respond calmly and correctly. I audit websites for accessibility by hand. I am not a lawyer. I explain who can send an accessibility Abmahnung in Germany. You will learn what is known about past cases and which steps to take now.

In short
  • Do not let the deadline pass. Otherwise the sender can apply for a preliminary injunction [1].
  • Do not sign a pre-drafted cease-and-desist declaration without advice from a specialized lawyer [2].
  • It is legally unclear whether competitors can send warning letters for BFSG violations under § 3a UWG [3].
  • The market surveillance authority does not send warning letters. It acts through administrative proceedings under the BFSG [4].
  • The 6 steps after a BFSG warning letter are further down this page.

What is an Abmahnung (warning letter)?​

An Abmahnung is a formal letter sent before any court proceedings. The sender accuses you of breaking the law. The sender demands that you stop this conduct in the future.

The rules are set out in the German Act Against Unfair Competition (Gesetz gegen den unlauteren Wettbewerb, UWG). Under § 13 Para. 1 UWG, the sender should give you the chance to settle the dispute out of court [5]. You do this by signing a cease-and-desist declaration (Unterlassungserklärung) that includes a reasonable contractual penalty.

Under § 13 Para. 2 UWG, a warning letter must clearly and understandably state [5]:

  • the name or company name of the sender and, where applicable, of the sender's representative
  • why the sender is entitled to make the claim
  • whether the sender claims reimbursement of costs, how much and how the amount is calculated
  • the infringement, with the specific circumstances
  • in the cases under § 13 Para. 4 UWG, a notice that no reimbursement of costs can be claimed

If one of these items is missing, the sender cannot claim reimbursement of costs (§ 13 Para. 3 UWG). You may then even claim your own defense costs. This claim is capped at the amount that the sender demands (§ 13 Para. 5 UWG) [5]. If the warning letter is unjustified, you have no such claim when the sender could not have recognized the error [5].

Competitors also cannot claim reimbursement of costs for breaches of information duties in e-commerce (§ 13 Para. 4 No. 1 UWG) [5]. Ask your lawyer whether this covers a missing accessibility statement, for example.

A warning letter is not a fine

People who search for "BFSG penalties" often mean fines or warning letters. These are two different things. Only the state imposes a fine under § 37 BFSG, not a competitor [4]. I explain the fine ranges of up to €100,000 in the article on risks and fines for non-compliance with the BFSG.

Who can send an accessibility warning letter in Germany?​

The BFSG itself does not provide for warning letters. An accessibility warning letter therefore relies on the UWG. § 8 Para. 3 UWG lists who may bring claims for an injunction [5]:

  1. any competitor that sells or purchases goods or services "to a not insignificant extent and not just occasionally"
  2. qualified trade associations on the list under § 8b UWG, if enough companies from the same market are members
  3. qualified consumer associations on the list under § 4 of the Injunctions Act (Unterlassungsklagengesetz), and equivalent bodies from other EU countries
  4. chambers of industry and commerce, craft organizations, other professional bodies and trade unions, within the scope of their duties

All four require an unfair commercial practice. To show this, the first known BFSG warning letter relied on § 3a UWG, among other grounds [6].

The open question: is the BFSG a market conduct rule?​

In my own English translation, § 3a UWG reads: "Unfair conduct is committed by anyone who violates a statutory provision that is also intended to regulate market conduct in the interest of market participants, where the violation is suited to appreciably harm the interests of consumers, other market participants or competitors." [5]

It is disputed whether the BFSG duties are such market conduct rules. The Munich law firm Loschelder Leisenberg sets out both sides [3]:

  • For: The BFSG places extensive duties on companies. A company that does not meet them gains an advantage over competitors that comply with the law.
  • Against: The legislative materials (Bundestag document BT-Drs. 19/28653) contain no indication that the BFSG is meant to create market conduct rules.

There is also the question of the competitive relationship. The sender must really be your competitor. Trusted Shops doubts exactly this for the first warning letters [7].

As of September 26, 2026, I have not found any published court decision on this question. Loschelder Leisenberg expects the courts to settle it [3]. Until then, each lawyer assesses the risk for themselves.

What associations and consumers can do under the BFSG​

The BFSG gives consumers and associations their own rights. But these rights are directed at the authority or at a conciliation body, not at you directly [4].

RouteWhoLegal basis
Application to the authorityConsumers, also through an association that represents them§ 32 Para. 1 BFSG
Own application to the authorityRecognized disability associations and qualified consumer associations§ 32 Para. 2 BFSG
Legal remedy against the authority's decision or inactionAssociations, on behalf of consumers or in their own right§ 33 BFSG
ConciliationConsumers and the same associations§ 34 BFSG

Recognized associations are those under § 15 Para. 3 of the German Disability Equality Act (Behindertengleichstellungsgesetz). Consumer associations are bodies under § 3 Para. 1 Sentence 1 No. 1 of the Injunctions Act. An association can apply even if its own rights have not been violated (§ 32 Para. 2 BFSG) [4].

What matters to you: after an application, you get the chance to respond (§ 32 Para. 1 Sentence 3 BFSG). The authority decides by issuing a formal decision, called a Bescheid (§ 32 Para. 3 BFSG). While conciliation is under way, the authority suspends its proceedings (§ 34 Para. 4 BFSG) [4].

BFSG warning letters in 2025 and 2026: what we know so far​

The BFSG has applied since June 28, 2025 [4]. The first warning letters arrived about six weeks later [6]. I only summarize cases here that law firms have reported publicly.

The first wave in August 2025​

The law firm CLAIM Rechtsanwalts GmbH sent letters on behalf of a web design provider [8]. The letters complained about a general lack of accessibility. They named no specific defects and only showed screenshots [6].

According to Carsten Föhlisch, the letters demanded [8]:

  • a cease-and-desist declaration with a penalty clause
  • €1,032.44 in legal fees
  • alternatively, a €595 settlement, payable within 10 days, without a cease-and-desist declaration but with an accessible website within 3 months

According to Föhlisch, the lawyer later received a reply and then wrote that his letter was not an Abmahnung. He called it a notice of possible BFSG violations [8]. According to the online retailers' association Händlerbund, the client itself offers to make websites accessible [1]. Trusted Shops had the impression that the main motive was financial [7].

Warning letters with an audit report in February 2026​

In February 2026, the law firm KBM Legal reported on warning letters from the Berlin law firm MK | Michael Krause [9]. The letter listed three violations:

  • an empty link
  • an element with extremely low contrast
  • a suspicious alt text

The letter demanded €1,784.10 net for the warning letter and €490 net for a website analysis. Together that is €2,706.18 gross. An audit report by K3 International GmbH was attached. KBM Legal considers this report flawed throughout [9]. The firm also calls the stated amount in dispute (Gegenstandswert) of €50,000 clearly excessive. In its view, the demand as a whole is a clear sign of an abusive warning letter [9].

The three points map to WCAG success criteria: link purpose [10], contrast [11] and non-text content [12]. A tool flags issues like these quickly. Whether they really block people often only becomes clear in a manual test. In my audits, some tool findings turn out to be harmless when I test with a keyboard and a screen reader. Other real barriers only show up in a manual test.

I often see these three issues on WordPress websites. For example, an empty link can come from social media icons in the footer that have no link text. Low contrast often comes from light gray text colors in the theme. I can usually fix such barriers in the existing theme. Read more in the guide to making WordPress accessible.

Signs of an abusive warning letter​

A warning letter is inadmissible if it is abusive (§ 8c Para. 1 UWG). § 8c Para. 2 UWG lists indications of abuse [5]:

  • The warning letter mainly serves to generate fees or a contractual penalty.
  • A competitor sends a very large number of warning letters for the same kind of violation, relative to the size of its own business.
  • The amount in dispute is set unreasonably high.
  • The contractual penalty demanded is obviously excessive.
  • The cease-and-desist declaration obviously goes beyond the violation complained of.

If the warning letter is abusive, you can claim reimbursement of your defense costs (§ 8c Para. 3 UWG) [5]. Your lawyer will assess whether your case is abusive.

The MLBF: the market surveillance authority for the BFSG​

The authority for the BFSG is the MLBF, the joint market surveillance body of the German states for accessible products and services. Its full German name is Marktüberwachungsstelle der Länder für die Barrierefreiheit von Produkten und Dienstleistungen. It is a public-law institution based in Magdeburg [13]. All 16 German states run it together [14]. It started work on September 26, 2025. On that day, the interstate treaty of the German states took effect [15].

Consumers have two options with the MLBF:

  • Reporting a barrier: The MLBF takes the report into account in its market surveillance [16].
  • Application under § 32 BFSG: This starts administrative proceedings. They end with a written decision [17].

So a letter from the MLBF is not a warning letter. It is part of administrative proceedings with a hearing, a deadline and a formal decision. I explain how these proceedings work in the article on how an official compliance inspection works. Take such a letter just as seriously as a warning letter.

A warning letter can trigger duties toward the authority

If your service does not conform, § 14 Para. 4 BFSG requires corrective action. You must also inform the market surveillance authority without undue delay (§ 14 Para. 4 Sentence 2 BFSG) [4]. If you do not inform the authority, you risk a fine of up to €10,000 (§ 37 Para. 1 No. 2 in conjunction with Para. 2 BFSG) [4]. Ask your lawyer whether this duty applies in your case.

Received a BFSG warning letter? 6 steps​

These steps do not replace legal advice. They help you get through the first few days in an orderly way.

Note the deadline and do not ignore the letter​

Write down the date the letter arrived and the deadline. If you let the deadline pass, the sender can apply for a preliminary injunction [1]. Staying silent can lead to costs even if the sender is in the wrong [1].

Do not sign or pay anything in a hurry​

A cease-and-desist declaration is a contract. If you commit the violation again, you pay the contractual penalty, often several thousand euros [3]. So do not sign anything before a specialized lawyer has checked it [2]. And do not rush to pay a settlement offer [6].

Hire a specialized lawyer​

Look for a lawyer who specializes in competition law or intellectual property law. Loschelder Leisenberg recommends a certified specialist in this field (Fachanwalt für gewerblichen Rechtsschutz) [3]. Your lawyer can reject the claim. They can also consider a counter warning letter (Gegenabmahnung) or an action for a negative declaratory judgment [6].

Check the sender and the accusation​

Ask your lawyer these questions:

  • Is the sender really your competitor or an association with standing (§ 8 Para. 3 UWG)?
  • Does the warning letter contain all the information required by § 13 Para. 2 UWG?
  • Does it name specific barriers or only make general accusations?
  • Does the BFSG apply to your website at all?

The last question is often decisive. The BFSG applies to certain consumer services, for example e-commerce services (§ 1 Para. 3 No. 5 BFSG) [4]. Microenterprises that provide services are exempt (§ 3 Para. 3 BFSG) [4]. Check this with the BFSG relevance check and in the article on the microenterprise exemption. The article on which websites must be accessible gives an overview. For shops in Austria, the Austrian BaFG applies [18]. I explain the differences in the article on the Austrian Accessibility Act (BaFG).

Document the barriers and fix them​

Take dated screenshots of the parts of the website that the letter names. Then check whether the barriers really exist. Fix real barriers in the code, not with an overlay. I explain why an overlay is not enough in the article on overlays and the BFSG.

Fixing the barriers does not end the dispute on its own. According to case law, the risk of repetition (Wiederholungsgefahr) does not disappear just because you stop the conduct [19]. Fix the barriers right away anyway. Every barrier you remove helps your users and lowers the risk of further proceedings.

Get a manual audit as evidence​

An audit report shows your lawyer which barriers exist and which do not. It gives your reply a factual basis. But it does not replace a legal assessment.

In my manual audit, I test all 55 WCAG 2.2 A/AA success criteria by hand. Each finding names the location, the criterion and how I confirmed it with a keyboard and a screen reader. After a warning letter, I usually recommend the BFSG-Prüfung: my audit of the whole website for €1,490 net. That way, your lawyer sees where every page stands. The Basis-Audit for €490 net covers the homepage and 4 subpages.

In both cases, I select the pages according to Annex 1 of the BFSG. The authority also uses this annex to pick its sample [4]. Afterwards, I can fix the barriers in your existing theme. The article on website accessibility costs shows the total cost of audit and remediation.

Want to know first how serious your situation is? Book a free 15-minute call. I will tell you which barriers I see on your website. The legal assessment stays with your lawyer.

Prevention: how to lower the risk of a warning letter​

A website without real barriers gives the sender of a warning letter little to attack. These three points help:

  1. Publish an accessibility statement: It is mandatory under § 14 Para. 1 No. 2 BFSG [4]. Use our accessibility statement template.
  2. Have your website tested by hand: An automated test finds only some of the problems. Our free check tests 20 of the 55 criteria automatically, at least in part. The other 35 can only be tested manually, because they depend on context and meaning.
  3. Fix barriers in the code: Plan the fixes by priority. Start with forms, navigation and checkout.

Our BFSG audit example shows what a complete audit report looks like.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)​

This is not settled yet. A warning letter from a competitor requires the BFSG to be a market conduct rule under § 3a UWG. There are arguments for and against [3]. As of September 26, 2026, I have not found any published court decision.

What happens if I ignore an accessibility warning letter?​

The sender can apply for a preliminary injunction. You then risk costs, even if the sender is in the wrong [1]. So always respond within the deadline, ideally through a lawyer.

Can the MLBF send me a warning letter?​

No. The MLBF is the market surveillance authority of the German states for the BFSG [13]. It does not send warning letters under the UWG. It acts through administrative proceedings, for example after an application under § 32 BFSG [17]. It decides on such an application by issuing a formal decision (§ 32 Para. 3 BFSG) [4].

Is it enough to fix the barriers quickly after a warning letter?​

For your users, yes. For the dispute, usually not. According to case law, the risk of repetition does not disappear just because you end the violation [19]. Fix the barriers right away anyway, and clarify the cease-and-desist declaration with your lawyer.

How much does a BFSG warning letter cost?​

In two publicly reported cases, the senders demanded €1,032.44 in legal fees (or €595 as a settlement) and €2,706.18 gross [8], [9]. A contractual penalty can come on top if you sign a cease-and-desist declaration and then commit the violation again [5].


Disclaimer​

The content of this article has been researched to the best of my knowledge and is for general information only. It does not constitute legal advice and cannot replace individual advice from a lawyer who considers your specific situation.

The information on warning letters, amounts and authorities comes from the sources cited, as of September 2026. The legal situation on BFSG warning letters is not finally settled and can change through court decisions.

No guarantee is given for the accuracy, completeness or timeliness of the information. Any action you take based on the information provided here is at your own risk. If you have received a warning letter, please be sure to consult a specialized lawyer.


​

  1. S. May, “Unberechtigte BFSG-Abmahnungen: Ein Fall für den Papierkorb?” Aug. 12, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://ohn.haendlerbund.de/recht/rechtsfragen/unberechtigte-bfsg-abmahnungen-papierkorb ⤴
  2. F. Weiß, “Abmahnung wegen Verstoß gegen das Barrierefreiheitsstärkungsgesetz (BFSG).” July 07, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.ratgeberrecht.eu/aktuell/abmahnung-wegen-verstoss-gegen-das-barrierefreiheitsstaerkungsgesetz-bfsg/ ⤴
  3. Loschelder Leisenberg Rechtsanwälte, “Abmahnung BFSG Barrierefreiheitsstärkungsgesetz.” Apr. 10, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://ll-ip.com/aktuelles/abmahnung-bfsg-anwalt-de/ ⤴
  4. Bundesministerium der Justiz und für Verbraucherschutz, “Gesetz zur Umsetzung der Richtlinie (EU) 2019/882 des Europäischen Parlaments und des Rates über die Barrierefreiheitsanforderungen für Produkte und Dienstleistungen (Barrierefreiheitsstärkungsgesetz – BFSG).” 2023. [Online]. Available: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bfsg/ ⤴
  5. Bundesministerium der Justiz und für Verbraucherschutz, “Gesetz gegen den unlauteren Wettbewerb (UWG).” 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/uwg_2004/ ⤴
  6. L. Ferme, “Erste BFSG-Abmahnungen – das solltest du jetzt tun!” Aug. 14, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://business.trustedshops.de/blog/legal/bfsg-abmahnungen ⤴
  7. C. Föhlisch, “Update: Abmahnung CLAIM Rechtsanwalts GmbH wegen Verstößen gegen das BFSG – Barrierefreiheit.” Aug. 18, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://foehlisch.com/abmahnung-claim-rechtsanwalts-gmbh-wegen-verstoessen-gegen-das-bfsg-barrierefreiheit/ ⤴
  8. W3C, “Success Criterion 2.4.4 Link Purpose (In Context),” 2023, [Online]. Available: https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG22/#link-purpose-in-context ⤴
  9. W3C, “Success Criterion 1.4.3 Contrast (Minimum),” 2023, [Online]. Available: https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG22/#contrast-minimum ⤴
  10. W3C, “Success Criterion 1.1.1 Non-text Content,” 2023, [Online]. Available: https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG22/#non-text-content ⤴
  11. Marktüberwachungsstelle der Länder für die Barrierefreiheit von Produkten und Dienstleistungen (MLBF), “Marktüberwachungsstelle der Länder für die Barrierefreiheit von Produkten und Dienstleistungen.” 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.mlbf-barrierefrei.de/ ⤴
  12. Staatskanzlei Sachsen-Anhalt, “Neue Behörde der 16 Bundesländer in Magdeburg überwacht Barrierefreiheit von Produkten und Dienstleistungen.” Mar. 18, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://presse.sachsen-anhalt.de/staatskanzlei/2025/03/18/neue-behoerde-der-16-bundeslaender-in-magdeburg-ueberwacht-barrierefreiheit-von-produkten-und-dienstleistungen ⤴
  13. Landesportal Schleswig-Holstein, “Marktüberwachungsstelle der Länder für die Barrierefreiheit von Produkten und Dienstleistungen.” 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.schleswig-holstein.de/DE/fachinhalte/A/arbeitsschutz/mlbf ⤴
  14. Marktüberwachungsstelle der Länder für die Barrierefreiheit von Produkten und Dienstleistungen, “Meldung von Barrieren.” 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.mlbf-barrierefrei.de/Informationen-für-Verbraucherinnen-und-Verbraucher/Meldung-von-Barrieren/ ⤴
  15. Marktüberwachungsstelle der Länder für die Barrierefreiheit von Produkten und Dienstleistungen, “Antrag nach Paragraf 32 Absatz 1 BFSG.” 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.mlbf-barrierefrei.de/Informationen-für-Verbraucherinnen-und-Verbraucher/Antrag-nach-Paragraf-32-Absatz-1-BFSG/ ⤴
  16. Republik Österreich, “Bundesgesetz über Barrierefreiheitsanforderungen für Produkte und Dienstleistungen (Barrierefreiheitsgesetz – BaFG), BGBl. I Nr. 76/2023, Bundesrecht konsolidiert, Fassung vom 26.09.2026.” 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/GeltendeFassung.wxe?Abfrage=Bundesnormen&Gesetzesnummer=20012316 ⤴
  17. H.-J. Omsels, “Wiederholungs- oder Erstbegehungsgefahr.” 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.omsels.info/iv-die-ansprueche-oder-was-droht-wem-von-wem/b-unterlassungsanspruch/4-wiederholungs-oder-erstbegehungsgefahr ⤴

About the author

Portrait of Dmitry Dugarev

Best regards,

Dmitry Dugarev

Founder of Barrierenlos℠. I test websites by hand and fix the barriers on WordPress websites – without a relaunch.